Originally Posted By: copper91CalCoyote, You read my mind on the fps dilemma.
But, This reamer was a brainchild of gunsmith jerry Simison and it was designed to push 190's for 600-1000yd stuff. Anyway, it is not a straight 30-284 but i don't know the exact dimensions.
My buddy was running one for the long range BR game and was getting close to 300wm speeds with 190's.
So, my buddy says i will get somewhere between the 30-06 and 300WM. We ran the straight 30-284 through a program and it says around 3500 with 130's but high on the pressure chart so i'm thinking maybe with the exra capacity it will work.
I'll post when done,,, brux 14 twist should be here shortly.
There are two .30-284 cartridges listed in QuickLoad. One is labeled .30-284 @ 66 water grains and 59,465 psi rating, the other is a .30-284Win @ 67 water grains and 55,114 psi. I don't know which one, if either, matches your brass. FWIW: Neither will push a 130g bullet to 3,500 fps within it's max pressure limits out of a 26" barrel. The Winchester needs 67,000 psi to get there in models which is ~22% past max, the other needs 68,102 psi which is 14.5% above it's max pressure rating.
The better of the two needs a barrel 34" long to get there at exactly the max rated pressure.
OTOH, with the intent to bring a solution rather than just issues:
A .30-338 Lapua would get you there (130g @ 3,500 fps) nicely within rated pressures. If you haven't chambered it yet you might consider that as an option. My model load for the .30-338 Lapua (same bullet as above, 26" barrel, 90.3g of IMR7828SSC) easily gets 3,513 out of a 26" barrel @ 56,000 psi in 64,000 psi rated brass. No muss, no fuss, no magic, just solid performance. Excellent brass and bullets easy to find for that cartridge.
There is no magic in cartridges, only physics. Physics is what it is. It isn't negotiable. Nobody can fool mother nature. It doesn't behave differently for big name reamer designers than it does for anybody else. You pay your money, you take your chances.
My all time favorite quote on technology comes to mind looking at this data - it is the last sentence from the Appendix to the Rogers Commission Report on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident" titled "Personal observations on the reliability of the Shuttle", by R. P. Feynman:
For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled.
Feynman got it right.
YMMV.
Fitch