From my Benelli M1's the Indian Creek BDS gives me over 200 pellet strikes in a 10" circle at 40 measured yards with 3" Hevi 13 #6's. A Kick's GT will do about 170 - 175 with the same load. Either one will do the job nicely, but that Indian Creek is a shredder, pure and simple. I have another IC-BDS on a 20 gauge 870 with a 21" barrel and it will break 115 hits in 10" @ 40 yards. That makes the little 20 a reliable and consistent 40 yard turkey killer. Not every choke is going to do that in a 20 gauge. Anyway, for me the Indian Creek has proven to be worth the extra cost. Besides, you only have to buy it once, as opposed to buying two or three less expensive chokes that don't work out and end up rattling around in a drawer. That's my take on it anyway, others will have different ideas.