Originally Posted By: twhitey Why put him into a low budget setup and wish you did something else.
Because he asked for a scope at around $1,000. It's just that simple. Don't try to sell him a $3,000 to $4,000 outfit if his budget is $1,000.
Good advice from people who have been there and done that is generally a good thing, but it needs to be offered with experiences and not "I think," and not the same old "keep saving" or "save your money for a Gen 3" stuff that is quickly becoming worn out.
People who offer advice need to have some experience with such things, which includes the latest scopes on the market. If anyone had bad experiences back when Gen 1 was all that was available for under $1,000, and if that's what they base their advice on today, then really that advice is not worth much, given today's new scopes and illuminators.
I heard the same old thing about Gen 1's, but that was all I could afford, rather it was all I was willing to pay at the time and so I purchased one. It got me into the night vision game and I enjoyed the heck out of it. It wasn't great, had a lot of limitations and wasn't suited for every type of hunting situation, but man it was far better than the continuous "Gen 1 is junk" stuff that I was hearing so often. I made it work with proper IR lighting and dropped 6 coyotes with it at my bait site. Since then some on the forums have changed their tune just a wee bit to say that Gen 1 is junk unless you use it at a bait site. Wonder where that idea came from. In my mind, I questioned if anyone had experience with a Gen 1 at a bait site when they offered their expert advice. I think most didn't. I proved the Gen 1 does have usefulness, though admittedly limited.
The bottom line is this - not everyone can afford high dollar scopes, and not everyone wants one even if they can afford it. There are people like me who could afford one if I really wanted it or needed it. Turning loose of $4,000 for a scope is just something I can't picture myself doing, not because I can't afford it right now, but because I don't need it and can't justify it. Does that mean that I should not enjoy night vision because I won't get that kind of scope? Heck no.