How do you know they aren’t coming to prey calls? Or are you just not seeing them come in? I haven’t found anything yet that doesn’t respond to prey calls, except possums, they don’t come in to anything. Called in a coon the other night playing baby rabbit at a low volume.
Most likely it’s your setup. I’m still fairly new at this, but what works best for me is to go listen and mark coyotes I hear on OnX. If I don’t hear any, I’ll try some coyote vocals just to illicit a response and mark that location.
I’ll then back out and figure out the best winds and best spots to call from and wait for the best night to call. Generally when I go back I’m within a couple hundred yards at most from them. If they sound off and I can get closer I’ll do it.
I’ve been starting off lately with a good 10-15min of prey sounds, if nothing I’ll give it 5-10min of silence before I start in with coyote vocals. It all depends on if and how they respond as to what I go to next.
I had a pair respond back and forth for almost 30min and they were within 100yds of the caller and wouldn’t budge. I finally went quiet for 10-15min then started back with low volume Tiny Bunny and they came charging in.
With that said I’ve had a lonely female howl going at max volume and one came charging in and almost stuck his nose in the call before I was able to get a shot.
For me the ultimate coyote vocal is some type of pup crying/squalls/distress sound. They do not stop for me when that’s playing so you better be quick and good. We’ve had them come from dead behind us and my son shot one less that 10yds. It was a “self defense” shot, lol.