I believe sometimes people get a bad product. I’ve had a few lemons in a various product lines over the years.
I don’t believe in bashing or downplaying a product because you can’t or won’t buy one.
I also don’t believe in saying this light is an X-yard identifier.... because you can see a lot better in some scopes than others.
I am quite fond of the Fireye light from FoxPro. If it could be mounted on a scope, I’d switch.