Personally, I'd go with the Leupold. I own two of each manufacturers scopes. I recently bought two Nikon Buckmasters and ended up having to send one of them to their Customer Service Center for a flaw in the glass piece that was minor. They cleaned the scope alright, didn't charge me, but it came back with clearly the same flaw that any blind man could see when looking through the scope. So much for their wonderful Customer Service. I wasn't impressed.