Originally Posted By: SlickerThanSnotOriginally Posted By: MatlockSo I just bought a Wilson headspace gauge to use for reloading AR-15 and now I'm completely confused on what I truly need. I know that you have to FL size each case for reliable feed, so my assumption was the Wilson gauge was the right way to go. Am I wrong?
full length size the cases just like you are doing for the ar and you probably do not need any stinking gauges.
never owned any kind of reloading gauge in my life (except for a good pair of calipers) and get along just fine.
while i agree that you can do everything a sheridan or wilson gauge can do with a set of calipers, a headspace bushing for a comparator for your caliber, an Ogive bushing for the bullet and a saami drawing to spec off of - one thing you cannot do is quick spot check ammo in a yes/no fashion very quickly while reloading with the caliper method.
the sheridan allows you to do a bunch of different measurements at once - body diameter, head diameter, headspace measurement, OAL check, and basic concentricity all at once.
a quick plunk test of every 5th or 10th round (or even every round) in the gauge gives you a definitive answer right there, and you then know if you need to get the calipers out to know exactly how much that loaded round is in fact out of spec - or just set it aside for more intense QC after your loading session, assuming of course you're not having the same issue show up repeatedly.
neither method is incorrect, and your caliper/drawing method is actually superior in some ways, but they both have their strength's and weaknesses.