Specifically "varmint Nightmare" I haven't used, but with other "inexpensive varmint" bullet(Dogtowns) here is what I have witnessed with 2 different rifles.
1) They are cheap, production tollerances are not stellar. So maybe a bad lot of bullets.
2) Dogtowns in particular, have a VERY light jacket! I went round and round with Midway, exchanged several emails and phone calls. They claim that "AS LONG AS YOU KEEP THEM UNDER 4000FPS, THEY'LL OUTSHOOT YOUR BEST BARREL". Well, maybe if you are using a 12/14 twist. What the truth is, is they have a RPM ceiling of about 230,000rpm. Meaning with your 9 twist you have to limit them to less than 3000 fps(depending upon barrel smoothness).
Probably you are spinning them apart, but they haven't yet "puffed". Just leaked enough core to start them tumbling.
Remember that Velocity really means nothing for bullets, RPM is the destroyer.
Here is a RPM calc for you.
MV * 720 / Twist
So: 3000fps * 720 / 9 === 240,000 RPM