Correct, I misspoke a little and the basement dwellers crawled out. The NICS check has no idea what your buying, the atf would need to do an audit of sales of tens of thousands to find all the suppressor sales your paranoid about. Betting I’ll be low on the list for that massive operation of 180ing from the press release they put out.
If your in a free state, don’t bother with dealers still running form 4 process
Ok not a basement dweller but your right on the NICS process they absolutely have no idea outside of rifle, pistol, other.. yeah I've been on both side of the counter (like many on here as well, and a lot has changed since I stopped being the "other side'). Here in lies the "but" automated 4473's, and here I don't know enough to speak with great authority. But, could they be reviewed remotely?? maybe?? maybe not depends on the software company (vendor) that the FFL is using. Not for sure and really nothing to get absolutely all wrap up in .
Hard paper forms yes they physically have to show up and go through every form to find on. Electronic I'm not so sure of.
But honestly what actual difference does it make either Form 4 or form 4473 if it's done legally as prescribed? nothing, if it's legal it's legal.
Is it wrong to be paranoid? I don't think so. For everyone that is that way well it's not that they are , But it what has the Feds done present, future, or in the past to make them feel that way. We all get a little carried away expressing our viewpoint on such topics. Do I personally have absolute trust in our agencies, no I don't as a rule, yet like a vast majority I want to have that trust.
The point is not to argue your point but to actually reinforce /agree with what you have stated "it's a Hard Lift" on the agencies part to track them down either way. But do I "think" they could? yes. But it has been that way for decades not just this topic but any relating to firearms sales. And quite honestly just felt like joining in with a view point or two. I was glad to see them flip back to the old method of the 4473 record keeping and allowing destruction after 20 years ( hopefully, I read that right on the last proposed ruling that finalized)
Now I've weighed in with my opinion and my preferred method I think clearly enough and pretty much explained why I feel the way I do. But at the end of the day if it's legal at the time of sale then it's legal. Be it form 4 or 4473. Pick your method it's basically just like insurance... picking is a personal choice .