17 WSM. How does it stack up as being a "pelt friendly" round?

tyler cagle

New member
So been thinking bout possibly the hottest little cartridge on the market right now and how it performs in the field. Me and Granpah have been thinking about purchesing one of these for some time, but all that was out on the market at that time was the one made by savage (piece of junk). now there are a few more brands that manufacture some higher quality 17 wsm's (Ruger problely being the most popular) and i was wondering how they perform as far as accuracy, range, minimal pelt damage, etc.
 
Coyotes? You will have more run offs than anchors. Brush up on your tracking skills if you are going to shoot coyotes with it.

Coons rabbits pdogs crows varmints, excellent round.
 
Originally Posted By: TheshedhunterCoyotes? You will have more run offs than anchors. Brush up on your tracking skills if you are going to shoot coyotes with it.

Coons rabbits pdogs crows varmints, excellent round.

How many coyotes have you shot with this round that ran off???? a few of my friends that own them have not had this problem---We have to use rim fire for night hunting here in Mich so the 17 wsm is used by many--i'v killed coons ,porky's, crows and small varmints with the 17 wsm but not a coyote yet-but with out a doubt I'd shoot one--keep with in a 125 yards and it will do fine---a friend took one at 200 recently and it did the job--------Though placement of the shot is very important but that goes for any cal--yote's are hard dying so place your shots---very fur friendly--------------svb
 
HI , I own one of your piece of junk Savages . I find it to be an excellent little rifle . I have the skinny barrel , plastic stock models and it is a joy to carry the many miles we walk each day daytime coon calling here in Iowa. It kills them real dead fast especially at the close ranges we have on our hunts 10 - 40 yrds on average. The longest shot I have made on a coon was around 80 yards between the eyes and the result was as expected. I use the 20 grain rounds and they will not exit on a coon , wood chuck , big feral cat with shot placed in center mass . The 25s have some copper frags coming through on close shots so I stick with the 20s. My son uses an HMR and it does real good also but with a little less " hammer of Thor " (smack) . Couldn't be more pleased with my rife. We take around 80 coons a year and my rifle is going to start its third season this fall so I have a good idea about the subject. We walk 6 - 12 miles in a day of hunting so a gun weighing 4.7 lbs , bare , is a big plus . Jim
 
Last edited:
Why not skip the 17wsm and go right for the 17 hornet. You will have a center fire rifle and down the road if you want to reload you can. Or you can turn around and sell the once fired brass and recoup some of your cost of factory ammo. IMO a rim fire is for small game say as big as a fox. Can it be used on coyotes (yes). But is it an ideal round for coyotes (no IMO).
 
Originally Posted By: tyler cagleIve killed a pregnant female yote with a 17 hmr at 25 yrds and she droped like a sack of potatos.

How much did you get for that pelt?

If you're killing em that time of year I don't know why the he11 you're asking about "fur friendly" anyway.

Kudo's for killing her before the pups were born so they didn't have to starve to death in the den though.
 
Im just now getting into trying to save the hides, and i just tossed the mama dog as furbearers with noticeable teats bring less money
 
Originally Posted By: RePeteOriginally Posted By: tyler cagleIve killed a pregnant female yote with a 17 hmr at 25 yrds and she droped like a sack of potatos.

How much did you get for that pelt?

If you're killing em that time of year I don't know why the he11 you're asking about "fur friendly" anyway.

Kudo's for killing her before the pups were born so they didn't have to starve to death in the den though. oh a heart bleeder. I have a few ranchers that would be happy he took out the female and the future calf stealers. We have so many coyotes that it wouldn't hurt the population up here. I think the PETA site is looking for guys like you.
 
I don't know Repete very well, but he and I have been here a while. He is much older than I, but that does not change a sportmens way of thinking. I like hunting and killing stuff as much or more that lots of hunters. I also don't like animals suffering ie: starving, legs shot off etc...

It is everyones job to look out for the critters and treat them with respect, while trying to let the air out of them !
tt2.gif


I'm sure Repete will agree, reguardless if he likes me or not.
 
Originally Posted By: tyler cagleHey man im just going off the reviews ive seen on the internet and my own personal experiance with savage

You may want to do a little more research then just reading a review/s, before you run out and buy a Ruger 77 17WSM or you could end up pretty disappointed. I know the folks I've talked to that have them sure were.

I'm sure you'll get those that praise how awesome they shoot right out of the box and, maybe, some of them even do but based on information I've got from actual owners, they were anything but impressed.

The Ruger 77 17WSM is by no means superior in it's shooting ability over the Savage Bmag and the Ruger, much like the Bmag, is NOT without it's issues. The triggers suck, the comb, like the other 77's, is to low, and most of the ones that, honestly, are shooting well have had the stock bed and or the muzzle re-crowned. Much like the Bmag, the Ruger tends to benefit quite nicely from having the stock either replaced or at the least, bed to the receiver. The trigger in the Ruger 17WSM is not good at all and at the least, you'll want to install a VQ target sear kit or better yet, replace it with an aftermarket trigger. The trigger in the Savage is pretty decent.

If you just like the Ruger better, it's your money, spend it however it pleases you but don't be surprised when your new 17 WSM shoots groups that are measured in inches and when someone tells you how great theirs is grouping, make sure you ask if those groups were shot at 50 or 100 yards. I hear all the time about these one inch groups but then you find out they were shot at 25 or 50 yards. lol

I'm in no way saying one is any better than the other, that's up to the individual to decide. It makes no difference to me what name is on the side of it, I just want it to shoot well and being that it's still just a rimfire, I'd rather spend my money on ammo, not the gun.

Here's a $$$ spent comparison for you on what I all have into my Savage HB SS Bmag and mine came with the POS plastic stock.

Gun $335-$25 Savage mail in rebate= $305
Boyd's Pro Varmint&metal trigger guard from DIP Inc. $140
Bedding+Shorten barrel 2in&re-crowned+threaded&thread protector made out of piece cut off=$220
Glades bolt handle=$52 (wasn't a needed item just like how they look)
1 Piece Pic rail from DIP Inc $38 (personal preference only, it comes with 2 pc weaver mount)
Total $755 I weight sorted some American Eagle 20gr ammo and the first group shot 1/2 and the second went 3/8 both at 100yds. I've chronographed mine with my Magnetospeed chronograph, with my 20in barrel the 20 grainers averaged 2984 FPS. The 24in barrel on the Ruger only shoots about 30 FPS faster with the same AE 20gr ammo.

If this was a Ruger 77 17WSM I'd have $750 in just the gun alone. Then add $220 for the same bedding job and barrel work. At least $40 for VQ target sear up to $125 for trigger replacement. Boyd's stock($100) or at the least a cheek pad for better cheek weld ($25). One piece Pic rail($38) but like the Savage, optional only. Total $1035 or $1233 if you choose to replace the stock, trigger, and used a 1pc pic rail.

You certainly don't have to do any of these things, well, except for the trigger because they're terrible, who knows, maybe, you'll luck out and just get one of those "good ones"...
 
Tyler, the .17 WSM should serve you better than any other option you have for now during modern gun deer season in Tennessee. Hopefully they'll change the law down there or or one of the gun companies will rerelease the .25 Stevens or .44 Henry rimfire:D

I know repete well enough that I'll say he ain't no dern bunny hugger. He just don't wanna see fur wasted, and if your killing pregnant yotes in the spring your wasting a bunch of prime winter fur.
 
Originally Posted By: deaddogwalkinIMO a rim fire is for small game say as big as a fox. Can it be used on coyotes (yes). But is it an ideal round for coyotes (no IMO).

I completely agree! My 17 WSM is a sage rat smashin SOB and is a lot of fun to shoot little critters with but the only way I'd ever grab it to go shoot yotes, is if it were mandatory per the area I was in or it was my only option.
 
Originally Posted By: tyler cagleHey man im just going off the reviews ive seen on the internet and my own personal experiance with savage

I bought a bmag, sent it back to savage and they sent me another. That one was also a POS. I will give savage credit, they gladly refunded my money.
 
As usual, just my opinion, but when there are so many better choices than the HMR and probably the WSM, why do people continue to want to use them to take game that they're not intended for? Sure they will kill a coyote but again and just my opinion, its not a good choice. From my limited experience, coyotes can be pretty tough critters to put down and a misplaced shot results in a runner and thats what we as hunters don't need. Mr. Tree Hugger doesn't need his kids seeing a wounded animal die in their front yard. JMO, I'll shut up.
 
If you already have a 17HMR, then bump up past the 17WSM to a 17 Hornet. As someone who loves the 17WSM, I would reach for a 17 Hornet before the WSM for coyote. Now, I do have some areas where I hunt, that the 17WSM is "almost" required for predators, and I have taken a handful of predators with it. However, the 17 Hornet will extend your range and give you much more energy when that bullet hits. With either choice, you will still have to have very good shot placement.

With regards to the Ruger. B23 posted a reply that should be strongly considered.

Eric
cool.gif
 
I suppose rimfire is the way to go, and i only hunt private property. Being a predator hunter has its perks, everyone wants coyotes dead. Noise would be a problem in some of my stand locations, but as far as deer hunters i have no worries. I created this topic cause i wanted to know how much better the wsm was compared to the hmr round. My CZ is not a bad gun i just wish it had a little more range. Im going to do some of my own research on the wsm
 
Back
Top