Having suffered a similar situation with my slick tricks, I spoke with a few "experts" that gave me a variety of things to check.
I did the following, in order, to get identical flight from my broadheads and field points:
1) full inspection of bow operation, cam timing, string twist, axles, etc., to be fully sure everything was working properly.
2) paper tuning- took a while, but I got my rig shooting bullet holes with bare shafts at 20 yds.
3) arrow tuning- ensured the nocks, inserts, shafts, points, and vanes were all perfectly concentric. Weighed each arrow bare and built to get the ultimate in consistency, and be dead sure each was as identical as I could possibly make it.
I tested my broadheads for concentricity too. Two of 8 were off slightly. They got tossed.
It takes a lot of time and effort to get a rig dialed in perfectly, but once its done, it helps a lot in discovering flaws in form too.
I took lessons from a couple local pros (competition shooters @ state level) who helped me identify my challenges, and how to overcome them.
I shoot 200 or so arrows a week, about half of which are blind bale, practicing perfect form for every shot.
The result of all this effort?
1" groups @ 20 with 5 arrows I can pull from the target with one hand.
Only took me 6 months to pull it all together, and practice to get myself to this level.
Next step - a 1" group at 30!
DDM