I haven't seen the place and know nothing about it. So, I don't know if it's open or woods country. All I know so far is it's 2 hours south on I77 from Cleveland.
I have quite a few guns though but I think it will boil down to the following,
Winchester 94 30-30
Model 70 .243 4x12 scope
model 700 .300 H&H 3x9 scope
Marlin 336c .35 Rem
Mossberg Mariner 12 gauge
I'm thinking one of the bolt rifles and one of the levers because I don't know if it's open country. Also, a S&W model 629. Decided to pass on my varmint rifles as I think I don't want to carry them around and they have hi power scopes.
Many more choices in the safe but I think these will cover what I need.