Gut shot deer with a perfect behind the shoulder shot

Coyote-conquest

Active member
This evening right at sunset I was sitting in the deer blind and heard sticks breaking behind me off to the left. It took a few minutes for a doe to finally pop out of the woods about 40 yards away.
She was weary of the blind and stopped dead in her tracks. I slowly stuck the muzzle/suppressor out of the window slit and found her in my scope. About that same time she started to turn slightly so I fired. She didnt turn much but Im pretty sure she was getting ready to go back in the woods. She did a 180 and took off into the woods.
I found some blood with chunks of what looked like stomach contents. I ended losing the trail. The woods had been logged around 20 years ago so its grown up thick with smaller trees, honeysuckle and ceder. It took about an hour but I eventually found her about 60 yards away. The first thing I noticed was shot placement looked perfect but the bullet wound had brown stuff coming out. I assumed I had hit the esophagus. I started to go ahead and gut her and to my horror I found her full of stomach contents along with poop and blood. The whole chest cavity and stomach area was full of a brown blood/poop mix. It was horrible and the first time Ive ever gut shot a deer.
I cant tell what happened. I used a 12.5" 6.8 SPC with 90gr Gold Dots so I dont think the bullet came apart. Instead of finishing gutting her I just quartered it.
The angle wasnt enough of an angle to go in the guts. Maybe ricochet into the guts? Maybe it sent bone shards? Either way I dont think ill ever shoot another behind the shoulder. I wouldve thought for sure it wouldve been a great shot. I think ill do neck and head shots for now on.
I attached a picture of the entrance. It wasnt a pass thru. I also have a picture where I cut her open and its all a brown runny mess but wasnt sure I should post it.
20261115_190252.jpg
 
it was the angle of the shot, bullet probably hit bone and went into the guts.

one year i shot a buck, hit it in the neck and down it went. it was leaving a small but noticeable blood trail in the snow. it had a bullet hole right behind the front leg.
i waited a little bit but no one came along tracking it.

i dressed it out and found that the bullet went in behind the front leg, never went into the chest cavity but came out between the front legs thru the brisket...a solid non fatal hit.

the other hunter arrived and we discussed what happened. he was in a tree stand and the buck was so close the shot was a steep down ward angle. the bullet went in, hit a rib and went straight out the bottom. never entering the chest, but looked like a solid heart / lung shot from the outside of the body.

since i broke its neck the deer was mine.
 
Over the years on the trapline after deer season I've had to kill more than one deer with the jaw or esophagus/windpipe shot away, heads and necks are small targets and don't slow a deer down for a couple days.

I usually aim for the high heart from any direction instead of just in the chest area, there is lots of area around the heart that is pretty deadly to a deer.
 
If thats the entrance and she was quartering to you then yes your into the diaphragm and beyond. Did you find the bullet ?
She was broad side when I went to shoot. She had just barely started to turn when I pulled the trigger so it wasnt a raking shot by any means. I wouldve assumed I wouldve had no problems.
No I didnt find the bullet. It wasnt a pass thru and I wasnt digging through all of it to find it. It was gross.
I assume the bullet glanced off a rib or another bone which sent it back.
Last year I shot one with a 240 gr lead bullet out of a lever action 44mag. It sent a shard of scapula bone through the liver. It was surprising how far it went. I wrote it off as a big bullet with a ton of energy
 
She was broad side when I went to shoot. She had just barely started to turn when I pulled the trigger so it wasnt a raking shot by any means. I wouldve assumed I wouldve had no problems.
No I didnt find the bullet. It wasnt a pass thru and I wasnt digging through all of it to find it. It was gross.
I assume the bullet glanced off a rib or another bone which sent it back.
Last year I shot one with a 240 gr lead bullet out of a lever action 44mag. It sent a shard of scapula bone through the liver. It was surprising how far it went. I wrote it off as a big bullet with a ton of energy
I can tell it wasnt a raking shot. Doesnt take much angle to get into the guts, It happens.
 
If I understand things correctly, she was turning as you were shooting. No way to tell just how much turning took place at the shot and before the bullet got there. Sounds 100% like an angle issue. Without really investigating things, finding the bullet etc., you'll never really know.
 
Bullets do weird things sometimes. I once shot a buck, aiming at the point of the shoulder with a .45-70 pushing a 405 gr. bullet at 1800 fps. The bullet hit just a touch high, penetrated the top of the shoulder, smashed the spine, then made a 90* turn and traveled down the neck for 16" and made another 90* turn and exited through the neck on the opposite side. I have seen a few other odd ballistic or forensic events over the years.

I dislike headshots; I think they are gruesome, and I just don't enjoy them. Headshot game makes for poor pictures, and if it is a buck, you just blew the skull cap apart. The neck shot is deadly, but you absolutely must know the anatomy of the game animal. Miss the spine, and you will likely have the animal run off to die a slow, torturous death. The spine is what, maybe 2"? Pretty small target. You need to have an accurate rifle and a skilled shooter to be consistently successful with neck shots. I have killed a lot of deer and hogs with neck shots. If you can do it, the results are like lightning striking the critter. Don't expect the heart/lung shot to do what you described with any regularity on a broadside shot. This event wouldn't sour me on heart/lung shots.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top