Kies AR uppers - Review

dcase

New member
There is next to nothing out there for reviews of Kies Firearms (Google it) and I wanted to share my experiences regarding Kies. I have purchased two AR uppers from them (Travis) and my review is as follows:

1. Both uppers were purchased through Joe Bobs outfitters and I cannot say enough good things about them. They have the best customer service in a time that no one seems to even know what that means not to mention outstanding prices and next day shipping. Joe bobs is the place to go. The first upper was a 7.62x39. If you know anything about these uppers they all have had problems with shooting military surplus ammo. The primers are set too far back.

I had been thinking about getting one for years and called and asked if the Kies would shoot military surplus ammo. I was told “yes” and asked no further questions (like if I had a custom trigger). I was unable to shoot many brands of military ammo and to make a long story short I needed a longer firing pin which Kies did provide and ended up needing to change triggers. It was an honest mistake and my light Jewel trigger had not been considered when I was told yes it would fire military ammo. I was very impressed when it was all said and done with what I could do with a 7.62x39. See my review on Joe Bobs.

2. Like I said the customer service (CS) from Joe Bobs was great however the CS from Kies was a bit lacking. The owners “bedside” manner is lacking but like I said I was taken care of and I liked the upper and the price enough to purchase another. I ordered a .264 LBC (6.5 Grendel) because I wanted a long-range, highly accurate, hunting platform.

When I received my .264 the first thing I noticed was the billet charging handle would not pull back. After several pulls it came back and the same thing kept repeating. I called Joe Bob’s immediately and they said I needed to call Kies. Kies told me they make “precision” weapons with “tight” tolerances and did not seem to be concerned. After about 15-20 minutes of charging the bolt the problem seem to get better. I did notice the smell of something getting hot and noticed that the metal had been worn on the billet charging handle. Travis later told me that this was “normal”. It did the same thing to two other charging handles from my other uppers.

I have had several AR’s all with scopes and not one of them did this. The other thing I noticed was the quality of the bolt carrier. It looked NOTHING like the quality of the bolt carrier from the Kies 7.62 or my 5.56 bushmaster. It looked like it had been finished with a file or 80 grit sand paper (Kies response to this was it was a better bolt and finish). I went to clean the weapon as I do whenever I get a new one and the barrel was extremely dirtly. It required an excessive amount of cleaning. Kies promotes their “nano-ceramic” bore liner that requires very little cleaning and that is exactly what I got from the first upper. I could clean the 7.62 after shooting wolf with about 5-6 patches. This required over 15 patches after shooting a few Hornady A-max. Later Kies told me this has happened with the .264 LBC from time-to-time.

I took the upper out to my shooting range and the groups were larger at 100 yrds than using wolf ammo through the 7.62. I was using Hornady Match A-max ammo. This was the final straw and I contacted Kies and shipped the upper back after going through over 60 rds (about $60 worth of ammo). I had sent them an e-mail with photos of the targets, pile of dirty cleaning patches, bolt carrier, and even included a few targets with the upper when shipping. I was told it would take a few weeks before they could look at it. I never received any kind of conformation that they received my upper. When I contacted them asking if they received it I was told it would be about 2 weeks before they could look at it. I assumed this meant they received it.

After several weeks I called and spoke to Travis the owner. He said that he was just looking at it and was taking it out to the range right after we spoke. That was a week ago. I sent another e-mail 5 days after he was supposed to have looked at it stating that this needed to be resolved by the end of the week once again with no response. I finally got ahold of Travis and he had made it to the range a week from when he told me he was going and it shot fine and sent me photos of the targets. They were good groups. He did mention that he fed the rounds in individually and not through the magazine. I did not think anything of this until I got to the range and got the EXACT same results as before. I had gone through about 53 rds when I remember this and individually fed 4 rds. I had a good group that looked like the ones Travis sent me. Ran the last 5 rds through the magazine and it spread out again. Why the [beeep] would you run rds individually through a magazine fed weapon to test it?

It was also suggested that maybe it was my scope mount, that I tightened it too hard or not hard enough. I went so far as to change scopes and mounts and nothing changed. Put the scope back on my 5.56 and 1 MOA groups from a 20 yr old 16” chrome lined bushmaster that has seen over 5000 rds. NOT THE SCOPE. NOT THE SHOOTER. I did this on the same day, same bench, same lower, same scope. I put on the 7.62x39 with lesser quality scope and got better groups with military surplus ammo. In science, this is called a well conducted experiment with limited variables. I was out of ammo so I could not continue my experiment but I had had enough. I wanted my money back. I contacted JoeBob’s and shipped it back to them at no cost to myself. They are going to work with me and I am waiting to get a full refund. It is taking a little longer than expected. I can tell they are getting irritated and I don’t blame them. I think JoeBob’s is caught in the middle and thus far I have no ill feeling towards them and would still do business with them.

Bottom line, I would NOT recommend Kies to my friends and would recommend that they spend a little extra money and go with another company. I am happy with the first one (7.62x39) however customer service is extremely important to me and Travis has a lot to learn about dealing with the customer. I found the following thread below regarding their customer service policy’s which I did NOT experience. They do a great job of talking when it suits them but they don’t walk the talk in my experience. I have been around weapons my whole life, I have my own shooting range, shot expert in the military and I do NOT like being dwelt with like an idiot when it comes to weapons. I am not a gunsmith nor do I claim to know everything about AR-15s but I do know how to shoot and I know when a weapon does not shoot the way it should. I have decided to go with D-tec for my .264 LBC. I spent some time on the phone with Mike (the owner) and I was very impressed. It is a bit more money but I bet it will be worth it.

(A thread found on this forum from Kies)
Jeff, Thank you for the introduction and thanks to the forum for having me.

This is the perfect forum as well, If any of you are thinking of a new rifle in the near or distant future, please give us a look, and let us know what you want.

We are a brand new company and we specialize in AR type rifles.

What sets us apart from the myriad of AR manufactures is, customer service, Quality, value, and if we dont build exactly what you want let us know and we will build it for you at a fair price. We also have a very nice 22LR upper, that functions great with standard walmart bulk ammo.

Customer service:
I am available almost any time you call our factory, if you have an issue, or just want to get some input on your next rifle, you can talk with me directly, if you are not able to reach me there, you can always reach me by email, and it is a great rarity if it takes me more then 1 day to answer, if it does it is because i am somewhere completely isolated on a hunting or fishing trip more then likely. So when ever you need us you will always be able to talk to a "gun person" not a professional salesman who doesn't know a BCG from a LPK.

Quality:
All our lowers are billet lowers, and in keeping with our ideals of a "One Rifle System" all our uppers are caliber marked.

Each upper be it in 22lr or 458socom or any other caliber, is lapped true and square for the best possible barrel to receiver geometry and fit.

Each upper ordered by an individual is built at the time of their order so that we can make any adjustments that customer may want.

Value:
Just have a look at our prices, and what you are getting.

If you have any questions, please feel free to email me.

Thanks
Travis
Kies Firearms

 
Last edited:
sorry you had a bad experance. hopefully it was a one off thing perhaps?

i contacted KIES about this time last year about their blast master comps, i talked to Travis for 45 mins about the comp, his 22 lr uppers and this barrels and how to clean them with the coatings they use in them...i felt VEARY pleased with the conversation...even bought a comp from him right then, recieved it in a veary timely manner, love the product. i liked the fact that he took time out of his day to vist with me and NOT just "ok, ok, ok , yep, can do, yep..thats 54 bucks!!" type thing.

i really dont have a dog in this fight i just thought id post what i have experanced with KIES..

based on what i have experanced, id work with them agian..no problem!

BRIZ
 
I haven't had one of their uppers, but this doesn't seem like the norm. I've got to applaud Kies for doing some neat innovating things. Melonited gas tube, affordable adjustable gas block, high quality lowers, to name a few. I hope your next experience with them is better.
 
Sorry to hear your's didn't work out. I'm reasonably happy with mine so far. My only significant complaint was the bolt carrier sounds like the one in your rifle. I'm still waiting to get that issue resolved. I'll check back in when I do.
 
How do I add pictures from my computer and I will post some photos of the bolt carrier, charging handle, etc. What are you doing about your bolt carrier?
 
Care to describe "reasonably" happy? What is being done about your bolt carrier and what are your concerns?
 
Drew, I am sorry you are still having issues with this upper, first of all, why would I load one at a time in a mag fed weapon? Because it aids in keeping me focused on my shooting and not hurrying additional shots, this is a personal preference when shooting paper for the best accuracy that i as an individual can produce.

Here are the test targets we shot with your upper.
Kiesfirearmsdrewcasetesttargets001.jpg


Kiesfirearmsdrewcasetesttargets002.jpg


As for the customer service you received, I don't know what we could have done to make it better.

List of issues and what we did to resolve them:

1. Not firing your surplus ammo:

First attempt at resolving them-
You called and stated that the only possible resolution to this was an extra long firing pin, and that it was the only thing that would solve it, I (Travis) Tried to talk to you about other problems, stating that we have not had an issue with firing pin length at all in the past, and that we test all 7.62 uppers with import (Russian) ammo to make sure that there are no issues using inexpensive ammo. Your further insisted that it had to be the firing pin. You then told me that if I did not send you a new firing pin that you would go to every forum you could to tell everyone that our products are junk, and that we give no customer service. We would have worked with you to resolve the problem through logic and experience, but you did not have an interest in that, so we bought an extended firing pin and sent it to you.

That did not solve the problem, so you called back and stated that the problem is that you need an extra heavy hammer spring, and again if we did not send you one immediately you would proceed to go all over the forums telling people about what junk we make. So in order to get you the spring we had to have them shipped over night to us and then ship it out to you.

This did not solve the problem either.

Then somehow it came to light that you are using an ultra light trigger hammer combo. We tried to explain that your problem was the light hammer, and that it did not carry enough energy to detonate the com bloc mil surplus ammo. You then told me that you had one of the best triggers made, and that it was not possible that the hammer was the culprit.

At this point in time, we had laid out a considerable amount of cash to try to make you happy, and we offered you one of our MKI drop in triggers for the discounted cost of $50 (which is far, far, far under what it costs us to produce one) more then anything we wanted you to have a good solid rifle that you would enjoy, but felt it would be nice if you at least tried to come to the party on this, as the problem was not with the KIES product, the problem was with your lower receiver. You said that you were not interested in spending anything on a trigger group as you had already paid $250 for your trigger, and that it would not solve the problem, as you already had a top of the line trigger.

After a week or so you called and wanted one of the triggers, and that if it solved the problem you would pay the $50, one was sent to you, and you reported back that it did not solve the problem, as you still had 3 light primer strikes out of 1000. More then likely this is due to dead primers, as we generally see about 5 in a case of russian ammo that will not even fire in an SKS.

We still have seen no payment on the trigger.


Issue set number 2:

EDIT TO ADD- We never stated that the rougher bolt was a superior finish in any way, we said that yes a very few had gotten through had a rough finish. Also we stated that the rough finish issue had been resolved and is no longer a problem.

It was due to an inconsistent phosphating, or so i have been told by the Metal treater we were using, however no longer are.

Smell when charging and a slightly tight bolt:

Nothing got hot to make that smell it was just the smell of the phosphate on the bolt rubbing, it happens sometimes and goes away in a few shots.

Rub marks on your charging handles:

Half the AR rifles i have owned (including, bushmasters, dpms, etc from before Kies existed) looked like this after a lot of use, and vigurous charging from one side.

Honestly, after you said that you put the charging handle in from the other rifle, and said you started to see wear on it, it started to sound to us like you were fishing for a couple free charging handles. After our last encounter, i think you can understand why.

More on the charging handle rubbing to follow.

Cleaning issue:

I have heard one other person with a 264 say that it was not easy to clean, I am not saying that it was common or that it happened from time to time with that caliber, it may be due to how you or they were cleaning it, if you did not clean the rest of your upper first, you can drag a patch though the fouling inside there, and it will seem to never get clean. More on this to follow.

Inaccurate upper:

First off i would like to apologize for the time it took, to test your upper, It is winter up here in Minnesota, and the weather did not co-operate for shooting out doors, when we wanted to test your upper for you.

When we received your upper, and were able to go test it the first thing we did was clean it, and it cleaned easy enough, just like it was supposed to. During the cleaning, I and 2 others checked for any sort of bur or anything else that would cause the handle to rub and could find nothing at all.

We then mounted a Pentax scope on it and went to test it,

We first got it on paper at 50 yards and calculated where we needed to set the scope for shooting at 100, at 100 yards I took two sighting shots to make sure the calculations were correct. Those 2 shots can be seen on one target. I then commenced to shoot 5, 3 shot groups of which can be seen in the target scans. The final group being a hot barrel group showing vertical stringing. Even in the hot barrel the group still measured at under an inch center to center.


I am sorry that it has come to this, I left your first three posts on this forum (about a month ago) here alone, including one you dug up from way earlier in April 2011 to elude to not being happy with your Kies products. I hoped that you would be satisfied, and did not see any point in getting into all these things online, and felt it would be in bad taste until now. However you left me no option but to defend publicly this company our products and our customer service.

Again, I apologize to the other members here that it had to come to this.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As for KLR drivers carrier, it is slightly out of spec, so we are replacing it with one of our new NiBor Carriers.
 
Also if you would like to put a rough dollar amount on what we have invested in to trying to satisfy you, here is the break down:

Firing pin, with all the shipping costs $40
Hammer spring with all the shipping costs $ 55
Trigger which should have been sold at a retail price $175
Test and sight in ammo $40
240 mile round trip to test your rifle as the local range was in accessible on the first day we were able to test your upper. 3.40 per gallon 16 miles to a gallon = $51
plus additional shipping costs, the upper back to you, the trigger group, cost of the ammo being shipped to us $50

total- $411

I wont even add in the cost of time, but at least 20 hours was spent trying to satisfy you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
To anyone reading this, BEWARE OF KIES! This man is NOT honest and his remarks regarding what I said and how things happened are COMPETELY FICTICIOUS! Ask yourself this, do you want to do business with someone capable of lying (not just lying, but making things up) on a forum regarding what you said? Read my comments and you decide who is telling the truth.

1. First of all, if you read the post it was not about the 7.62x39 at all nor did I even mention the trigger problems. I stated I was satisfied and obviously because I purchased a second. Go to Joe Bobs online and read my comments on Kies 7.62x39 upper and see if it matches Travis’s comments. NEVER, EVER did I even suggest that I would take any action regarding online reviews or anything of that nature in dealing with the problems we had with the trigger.

Travis states that several times I threaten them. I was extremely patient with them and again, if you read the reviews I have wrote, I felt things worked out pretty well and I am happy with that upper. It shoots GREAT! The problems were with the .264 LBC. Much later when I was getting no response from Travis regarding the .264 I did call and speak to one of his staff. I was very angry at this point because it had been several unanswered e-mails a week after he was supposed to have tested the .264 and close to a month from when they received it from me.

Once again, the person I spoke with was very nice and thanked me for my patients. I did make a comment that this needed to be resolved as it had been a month with no reply regarding my concerns. I have the e-mails and would be happy to post them. I did mention that “I am the kind of person that likes to leave feedback good or bad and that I would like nothing more than to leave good feedback for Kies and have this be resolved to both our satisfaction”. I was getting very impatient at this point. This is the second upper we are talking about. I had difficulty reaching Travis both times and he talked to me with the same finesse as he posted his reply.

2. Second, when I did call we discussed things and brainstormed ideas and came up with a plan together. My research pointed to the firing pin being the most common, cheapest, and simplest solution. This problem was not new to 7.62 uppers. Most everything else you put down is fictitious. Joe Bobs thanked me for my patients and stated several times how happy they were with how patient I had been as well as you did. It was not a bad experience, if it is as you described why would I have purchased another? GO READ THE REVIEWS!

3. Beings that you brought up the subject of the trigger problem. You are the expert, why did you not think to ask what trigger I had when we first had problems?

4. You mention the amount of cash you are out. I am out of a considerable amount of cash in lost ammo not to mention time and patients. How about how many times I drove to the range only to be disappointed with both uppers? I have spent over $100 in .264 ammo and shipping costs too. It cost me another $50 to have your “drop-in” trigger put in by my gunsmith. Do I really need him to get in this to confirm that he had to make slight modifications to my safety and to the pins to get the trigger in? I would be happy to comment on this further if needed. I would be happy to send your trigger back if you get me a full refund on my .264 upper.

5. I did call and ask for the trigger as we discussed if the other things did not work and they did not. I got the trigger put in and in combination with the longer firing pin (model 1 sales, look it up) problem was solved as I reported back to you and stated on my review at JoeBob’s. I absolutely did not call back and say anything about 3 lite strikes out of 1000. I have not even fired close to a thousand rds through the upper. I may have told them I had 3 out of 100 using cheap ammo and I was happy with that. Like I said, I love my 7.62 upper. and none of my review was based on that.

6. As soon as I figure out how to post pictures, I will let the pictures do the talking. Why would I want more charging handles Travis? Are you seriously going that low to make such a comment? There was nothing wrong with the ones I have. My concern was out of the box, I could not pull the charging handle and when you see the picture you can very clearly see the wear and why I had the problem. I spoke with several people including manufactures and gunsmiths and the wear I had is not “normal”. If you purchased a gun at a local store and got home and were unable to pull the charging handle, would you consider this normal? How would you feel if you took it back and they just said "thats normal"?

7. After reading Travis’s response, I would not be surprised if the targets he included and posted were from a different rifle as clearly he is very capable of distorting the truth and even flat out lying.

8. I felt my review was an honest and accurate account of my experience. I like to have an idea of who I am dealing with when it comes to spending money and I wanted to offer to those looking for feedback on Kies that I was unable to find. After reading Travis’s response I am quite convinced I know the kind of man he is and how he does bussiness as I would guess many of you do.

This man is not honest and has no honor. I have ZERO respect for individuals that lie. Travis, you just showed your true colors my friend!

Are you willing to take your product back and stand behind your words of “customer service”?

I was going to post my response and then I read Travis’s further comments. Travis, you are making my point for me. You are so way out there my friend. I ordered the firing pin myself and it was about $20. You did not pay a cent for that, you did however send me an additional magazine for the rifle to compensate me. You were supposed to send me a 30rd mag but you sent me a 5rd mag but I said nothing, we were working to get things fixed. You don’t even sell your magazine for $40. The springs were around $13. Go to model one and see for yourself.

http://www.model1sales.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=category.display&category_id=421

You drove 240 miles just to test my upper? Folks, I really can’t even respond Travis has said it for me! Good luck.
 
Originally Posted By: dcaseCare to describe "reasonably" happy? What is being done about your bolt carrier and what are your concerns?

As I mentioned in my initial review, as delivered, the upper wouldn't extract. A Wolff extractor spring fixed that. The machining on the bolt carrier was pretty rough, but the real problem is/was the bore has a step the gas rings have to jump to get into the bore (my other ARs are beveled). This makes it a significant pain to get the bolt back in after cleaning. Travis has promised to replace the BC with one of his new generation Ni-Bor carriers when they become available. We're keeping in touch on that.

As to accuracy, mine shoots 5 rounds of 123 Amax over 8208 well under MOA fed from the mag. I don't use a vice, just a Rock jr. cheapo rest and a bag on the rear. I'm trying to see what it will do with 108 Scenars (again over 8208). At present, it's doing a wee bit better than MOA but not as good as the Amaxs. I'd like to shoot one hole 5 shot groups. Maybe someday. The bottom line? The rifle shoots (or I can shoot it - I'm not really much of a precision shooter) as advertised if not a wee bit better.

No real issues cleaning. After the last outing shooting 50 of the 108s and about 20 amaxs it took about 20 patches and an overnight soak to get it clean. However, I had not cleaned the barrel since my last outing (about 30 amaxs) which may be part of that. Or, the 108s may copper the barrel worse than the Hornadys.

All in all, I like it. Would I buy another? Probably. Again, the bolt carrier is my only real issue and Travis seems intent on solving that.
 
Last edited:
Best of luck, I hope it works out for you. I am just hoping to get my money back and call it a day. I have been looking at D-tec and heard really good things about them.
 
Dcase, with all do respect, you are NOT doing your self any favors by bashing someone with first few and ONLY post.

I have had a few dealings with Travis over the phone and in email and have never had any problem with him getting back to me.

In September of this year I purchased a .264 LCB- Ar with Kies Delta Rail directly from Kies as well as another blastmaster for my SD .264. Overall I was more that satisfied with the work and the upper I purchased shot sub MOA with factory hornady ammo. Keis's billet charging handle is heavier built than others, my barrel was clean upon delivery and easy to clean following five shots. The Delta rail was extremely nice and well built and overall I was happy with it.
 
Last edited:
Drew,

I am not in any way lying, all i did was lay out what had happened from day one regarding our dealings with you, so that it would all be out on the table. Furthermore, i do not appreciate being called a liar, every customer we have had has been happy with our products, and our service, save one who at the end of the day found out that it was actually the magazine causing the problems.

as for the price of the springs and firing pin, the costs are low, for the part itself, but there are also the costs of shipping, we ship via fedex, and the cost for each small part to you was $15, you need to take that into account. The cost of having your extra power trigger spring shipped to us over night was $35, and then the cost of shipping it to you, and the cost of the spring itself.

You stated earlier that you ordered the parts from joebob, and it clearly lists that our uppers ship with a 5 round mag, as we can not know what state they will end up going to. So in order for our uppers to be compliant in as many states as possible we ship them with a 5 round mag.

As for how far i had to drive, it is 240 round trip, as most ranges anywhere near here are either private or short pistol ranges. there for in order to test your rifle the only place i knew of where i could shoot for sure, at the needed range of 100 yards, was at a family friends farm. I did this to try and get your upper diagnosed, any repairs needed and back to you as quickly as possible.


I believe that anyone can see you joined this forum to make good on your threats of running our name down, and you have made good on those threats. I am sure that this will hurt our business. I can only hope that our other customers whom are happy with our products will post as enthusiastic reviews in favor of our products. I still above all other things, even before this post wish that we could have made you happy.

As any of our other customers can and will tell anyone who asks, we produce a good product, and we stand behind them.

There is nothing wrong with the upper, however if what it takes to satisfy you on the 264 upper, yes we will take it back. just send it on in, and as long as it has not been intentionally, abused, or destroyed, we will refund you your purchase cost, as per Joebobs online price.

At this point, I believe i am done with this he said - he said game, as there is no point in continuing it with you.



 
Last edited by a moderator:
I understand what you are saying however my intent was not to bash but simply to leave my review (a honest one)of a company that is hard to find feedback on. I know lots of people have had a great experience with Kies by reading the reviews (the few out there) but that was not my experience. I have read a lot of reviews regarding AR uppers and many unhappy customers (of other companies) and I felt my review was honest, objective, and not improper in any way. I thought that was one of the main ideas of forums to share experiences positive or negative. I did get very angry when I was quoted as saying and doing things I did not say or do. I am honest to a fault and I do not respond well to lies. I appoligize, this was never my intent for it to go this far south. I never figured on Travis responding the way he did. I do believe in the freedom of speach good or bad and I stand behind what I said as the truth and my experience, which sadly was not as positive as others.
 
Dcase, I understand if you had a bad experience and want to inform others, but I just find it hard to consider you credible when your only post of this whole forum is negative post against Kies.
 
I also purchased a Kies 264 lbc upper and billet lower from Joe Bobs. The rifle has performed great shooting under moa with Sierra 120 Pro Hunter over 2520. Questions before and after the sale have been answered quickly by Travis and Joe Bobs.
 
I have a kies upper in 223 that I put on a lower I put together myself. I have nothing but great things to say about it. It's built well, functions great, and shoots dead nuts! I got it last year and it has been a great so far. I've shot some 3/4" 200yard groups with it lately when I've got to the range. (and I'm not known to be a great shooter)

I dealt with Travis several times when I was ordering it and found him friendly and easy to deal with. I'm starting a new build soon and when I do I have a feeling I'll be turning back his when it's time to have the upper built.
 
Back
Top