I have bow hunted for several years now. Most will agree that deer don't have jack on a coyote, but to think that a deer can not smell you at close range because you wear a fancy suit or have taken every precaution to eliminate your odor is very deceiving.
The first few years of my bow hunting experience I to bought into being absolutely scent free. I used unscented soap, took chlorophyll capsules, cut out my spicy food {which I love by the way}, washed my clothes in unscented soap, wore rubber boots, used cover scents, dressed{hunting clothes}only in the woods so on and so on you name it I did it to cover my scent.
I bow hunted for several years killing a few does but never a mature buck {till 2000}, I would catch glimpses of them in the distance but not up close. That's when I figured out that they were coming in down wind of me and cautiously leaving all the while never making a sound just leaving. They couldn't have caught wind of me after all I was "scent free", yea right!
Here's what I discovered later while hunting my favorite bow stand. I had to walk across the same trail the deer used to get to my stand. One day as I sat watching I had 8 does and 2 bucks walk down the trail I had used to get to my stand, which was on the upwind side of me. It had been 2 hours since I had walked the trail with very clean rubber boots that had been in a bag full of cedar branches. Ten deer total had walked the same trail I did and never acted like they could smell me at all. Or did they? My first thought was that all my precautions had paid off! yippee! Then it happened, a large old doe came down the same trail, when she hit where I crossed that trail you would have thought she saw Satan himself! She about broke her neck trying to get turned around and headed the other way, she stomped, she blew, and she ran back and forth and ran every deer there away with her. It blew my mind. How could the others not smell me? I played that day over and over in my head for days. Here's what I came up with. The 1 1/2 year olds were first there that day. They never slowed down coming in. 2 of the deer were 2 year olds they paused where I crossed and kept going. The last doe was at least a 4 or 5 year old with lots of experience, she knew I didn't belong there.
I wont even go into the pig{wild boars} thing, just know this, They can smell you. If they can find tubers and bulbs several feet deep they can smell you! I have heard they use hogs to locate old land mines in Vietnam.
Coyotes as mentioned have the nose of a dog and most have the ability to process the information collected by that nose at an unbelievable, extraordinary rate of speed. Yet all of us long time predator hunters have had coyotes come in down wind of us and act as if they couldn't smell us.
Now If I was using some fancy scent free soap, a suit designed to eliminate human odor or trying to prove how good my secret sauce was I could say that I had "fooled" their nose or they couldn't smell me.
Here's my take on this whole "scent free" situation and "fooling" the nose of most mammals and predators, 99.9 % of the time it can not be done. Why then do we think we have fooled some?
I think there are so many factors involved here that I can't mention them all and I doubt that I even know what some of them are. The few I know about are as follows;
Age- with age comes experience provided they live long enough. All of us have seen this in coyote pups and yearling deer. Let a mature animal get down wind of you I'm talking 4-5 year olds. Most will react, although some react different than we expect.
Wind- while we think we know which way the wind is blowing, this is not always true. It doesn't take much of a variance in terrain to change the course of the wind behind you. Just last week I had a coyote 5-6 feet on my down wind side. There’s no way he couldn't smell us. Or was there? While the wind was hitting me in the face, I sat back a ways with my friend still there and the wind behind him was blowing from his right. Something was changing the wind direction less than 2 feet behind us. It was a very dry 30-40 mph wind.
Temperature- as has been stated the temperature and amount of moisture in the air has a tremendous effect on how odors hang in the air.
Individual odor detecting capabilities- as most hounds men know not every dog can detect odors the same. Some trail the air some trail scent on the ground. Some track hot tracks some very old and cold tracks. So it would seem to reason that individual coyotes would vary as well. This may factor into the intelligence area as well.
Individual personalities- anyone with kids or dogs knows that each has its very own distinct personality. In fact every animal out there has a very distinct personality. Some are shy, some are aggressive and some cautious. I'm sure I left some out. Each of these will react differently to what they are smelling.
Intelligence- anyone who has dogs or kids know that each individual excels in different areas and well some are just plain not too smart. Of course the dumb coyotes don't live long unless their to dumb to investigate a call. I think I've met a few of those as well!
Human contact- we also have to figure in human contact and individual experience with humans. Some may be negative and some not so negative.
I'm not saying to be lazy. I still wash my clothes in scent free soap and use unscented deodorants. I use anti bacterial soap to bathe in, but I eat my Mexican food! After all you never know when it might help and there is no reason to amplify the situation with perfumes.
There are so many variables it's amazing. I think this is why some new hunters get discouraged and quit. Don't over think it just use what you know get out there hunt and USE THE WIND! It'll happen.