Montana pitch blend, is the best, Hubers is good also,
They are both pine tar,and Beeswax. Holds up good. I do my boots two or three times a year.I've been working cattle in 18 inches of wet snow everyday, granted been horseback part of the time, but also been in the alleys, and the "tub".
I rinse my boots in water every day when done. My "Filsons", and "Schnees",are holding up well, and dry feet, all day every day.These are the same boots I wear hunting.
"Muck" boots are nice for "chores", but they get destroyed in the rocks.They are warm, and dry, just not a "tough" boot.