Originally Posted By: skinneyOriginally Posted By: WyoBullA 22-250 with a 1:8 or 1:10 twist, in my mind, might as well be a 243 Win. Not saying at all that any support for a faster twist 22-250 is wrong, but if you want to shoot a 50-55 gr bullet and also want to shoot something heavier in the 70-100 grain category, my pick would be just a standard 243 Win.
I guess my mindset, after being a 220 Swift shooter for 40+ years, is to shoot the bullet weight the rifle was intended for. I picked up a 243 Win this past year after overlooking it for many years and it would be my choice if I were starting over with just one main caliber.
I would respectfully disagree, simply because anytime you introduce a larger diameter projectile, especially with greater than or equal to velocities, you also introduce the opportunity for more damage, at an exponential rate.
If you plan to keep what you harvest, cartridge and bullet selection are key, but so is shot placement.
I'm not a koolaid drinker when it comes to bullets or cartridges, I've used the 223, the Swift, the 250, the 22 Creed, the 6 creed, the 243, even up into the 6.5s, with more powder and bullet recipe's than I care to rehearse.
Regarding performance, whether it's the inherent accuracy that can be multiplied with precision, if you're willing to build a custom and amalgamate a reload with it. OR it's the diameter of the bullet in conjunction with it's ability to cause instant hydrostatic shock, with minimal (in most cases) fur damage. The 22-250 has proven it's worthiness over, and over, and over, to me.
I don't disagree with you at all on your points, they are valid and accurate. My only suggestion to the OP was that if you were only to have one rifle to shoot heavy down to lighter bullets, then I would pick the 243 as an example over the standard 22-250 only because you can load from 100 gr bullets down to 50 gr bullets with the standard 1:10 twist 243 Win. Doing that would give him a rifle he could hunt with for deer down to varmints.
If he is keeping fur, then yes, the smaller diameter .224 bullet is going to win with the right powder and bullet combination. I will always favor my 220 Swift but the heaviest bullet I shoot out of it is 55 gr with my favorite being the Sierra 55 gr HPBT (#1390). With that bullet, if I hit center mass, I get no exits.
The fun thing about all these different calibers and bullets is there are many ways to skin the cat and it is fun experimenting with different ones.