What caliber of rifle should I get ?

VarmintsBeware

New member
These are the calibers I am most interested in for Antelope-Deer-Elk hunting:

1. 7mm-08
2. 25-06
3. 308

Or should I go entirely different to be able to have a one gun for hunting.

Thanks,
Wayne
 
The most versatile and widely used chamber would be a 30-06. And I think this would suit you well. Another close second is the 270.

I am a big fan of the 7-08 and would feel rather confident using it for all critters listed.
 
The 25 is too light for elk. The 708 and 270 are pretty equal. The 308 can carry heavier loads than both, a 30-06 will go heavier still and a touch faster. Recoil on those 2 will be pretty much equal.

So depending on what you actually plan on doing and how often, and ignoring the argument that if you always have perfect shot placement and all other factors are always perfect you can use a 22lr on grizzly bear.

The 25 is good up through heavy deer. The 270 class will go a few steps beyond. The 30 class will go a bit beyond that. Of the 3 listed the 30 will have a bit more versatility. If you hunt preds and deer every year and may go elk hunting once in the next decade I'd go with the 25 and worry about an elk rifle someday. If I elk hunt every year, maybe moose every 3, I'd go with the heavier caliber.
 
Last edited:
When you throw Elk in the mix I gotta go along with the 30/06 crowd.
Personally though, at this stage of my life I prefer the 308 based cartriges due to their short action compatability and milder recoil.
As mentioned above, if Elk's not a yearly hunt, any of the three you listed will work fine.
Luck
 
Originally Posted By: NdIndyThe 25 is too light for elk.
Poppycock.
I wouldn't suggest it out of the 3 listed
Wouldn't be my first choice, but to flat out say its too light is nonsense.
 
I love the 7-08, my son shot his first elk with my wife's Rem Model 7, it is a nice, neat little package. As RePete stated, I too "prefer the 308 based cartriges due to their short action compatability." Now that I have broke my back twice (!) I like the lighter weight rifles that don't hammer me in the recoil department. The Remington site says that model 700 in 25-06 (now discontinued) weighed 7.5 lbs in CDL, a Model 7 CDL in 7mm-08 weighs 6.5 lbs. A full pound is significant to say the least!

I have also built a mauser 98 in .257 Roberts AI, competes with the 25-06 in fps and shoots factory roberts ammo if needed. Nice low-recoiling rifle. Shoots 120 gr bullets at 2875 fps or 100 gr at 3200 fps.

I have owned 300wby and 30-06 and 7mm Rem mag and am really moving towards the short action, low recoiling, non magnum chamberings that don't tell the world, "hey this guy needs to compensate for the size of his...."

have you considered the 260 rem? yet another option.

.
 
Outstanding comments, and I appreciate all of them. I am leaning towards 7mm-08 because I have never been elk hunting and have done alot of antelope and deer hunting.

I have used 7mm-08 before many times and really like it. I neve had a 25-06 before, but it looks like a real nice caliber.

So now all I have to do is find a brand of rifle that carries all three and see what styles/prices etc etc all three calibers come in.

Thank you once again everyone for your input.

Good luck hunting and happy shooting

Wayne
 

Everyone has their own ideas about things, nothing wrong with that. For what it's worth, I'll join in with my thoughts.

Your list of animals goes from small, rather easy to kill antelope at most likely extended ranges, to deer which can range anywhere from small to very large, and then on up to elk. That's a pretty tall order (in my mind at least) for any of the cartridges you listed to do a good job.

I've never hunted elk, would like to though. However, the late Bob Milek wrote an article one time pertaining to the 25-06 as an elk cartridge. He gave it pretty high marks. Bob was known as both a great guy and good marksman, one who knew quite a lot about rifles and loads, and put many of them into action on game. To my way of thinking, Bob was the kind of guy who had enough experience to make the 25-06 work on elk. I had the great priviledge of talking to Bob one time. He was indeed a very good man. I always enjoyed his articles and learned a lot from him.

The 25-06 is a great round. I've taken five antleope with that cartridge, a mule deer doe and a whitetail, plus a Corsican Ram. It's a great cartridge. For me personally, however, I consider it a middle of the road round when hunting larger game that antleope / deer.

The 7mm-08 is an inheritantly accurate cartridge, capable of shooting heavier bullets than the 25-06. It is generally considered a mid-range cartridge. It would be a great deer getter at moderate ranges, but could perhaps be a bit lacking on long-range antelope. My son took a huge Wyoming mule deer buck with his 7mm-08, at about 150 yards.

The .308 is an old standby, a good one too, and sadly one I have never owned.

You mentioned three of the "most interested in" cartridges, but you haven't necessairly ruled out other rounds, and are open to the idea of one rifle for everything.

My thoughts are go heavier since elk are involved and possibly heavy deer. A good 7mm magnum would work well for all the game you mentioned if considering just one cartridge. It's relatively flat shooting, packs a punch, and has a variety of bullet weights to do the job well on all three species.

There are so many good calibers available that it's just hard to choose only one. That's why we all like variety, and strive to lay our hands on something "just right" for the task at hand. It doesn't mean that we can't use something different, either lighter or heavier, it just means we look for the ideal cartridge, indeed if one exists.

For me, and elk hunting, I would reach for my 7mm STW or a .338 mag., or even the .300 win mag. simply because I have them in my gun rack and can lay a hand on either one of them. But, if all I had was a 25-06 and a burning desire to hunt elk, I would do it, but would choose my bullet carefully, notwithstanding distance and shot placement.

My two-cents worth may not be worth much, so take it with a grain of salt.


 
First Choice: 30-06 Bolt

Second Choice 308 AR

My 30-06 has by far killed most of my deer. Lots of good bullet choices to pick from. 165 Hornady SST works for me.
 
I saw some Savage model 11 and I think a model 111 in 25-06, 7mm-08 and one was in 7mm rem mag. All came as rifle/scope combos for about 499.00

I also some Ruger hawkeye rifles, one in wood/blue action and one in synthetic/stainless steel. Both were 308 and come with scope rings for about 599.00

I was thinking of the 7MM rem mag, just in case I do happen to get lucky and go on a Elk hunt. I know that caliber is cannon in regards to antelope and deer. I had a Win mod70 in 300 win mag and used it on antelope and both mule and whitetail deer. Also used it on a African Safari in 2003.

So now it is descision time on caliber and brand of rifle.

I appreciate all the input from everyone. Thanks so much

Wayne
 
well, they will all fit the job, just some better than others, if you can handle it i would recommend the 300 win mag if you will be elk hunting more than once. If not, 25-06 will be the flattest of the bunch. It's a good round with about as long a point blank range as any, almost as good as some of the wizz-bang super-ultra-short mags. Then there is the weatherby's......
 
.416 Taylor. I have one for sale....
wink.gif
 
Back
Top