What would you use for floor on Cabin. 1x6 Oak T&G or Laminate

rickyb

New member
Ok here is my dilemma. I already have down 3/4 CCA plywood on my cabin. I was going with the 1x6 T&G Oak down on that. My wife found some really pretty laminate called Arkansas Oak that she wants down instead. Price wise there the same. Here is what I face. On the T&G I have a round trip of 5 hours. After nailing it down to floor I have to sand it and then finish it with a stain.

The Laminate I have to lay down 5/8 plywood and then just put down the laminate.

No experience with either. What would you do. Rick
 
I’ve put laminate down on two separate floors. It’s a nice alternative to oak, but personally I like the oak better.

The first time I installed laminate it was a challenge because first it was my first time and second because the area that we were putting it in wasn’t completely level and we didn’t notice until half way through when we were having problems getting the boards to snap together. Another thing that we over looked was thoroughly inspecting each board before it goes down. We looked them over, but not good enough, there were still some chips on the boards that got past us. Also when you tap them together, don’t tap real hard or you will chip the two ends together. Another suggestion is to be sure that you have a good mat underneath. Again the first time I did it I opted for the inexpensive one and it made the floor sound much more hollower then it should had been, especially since it was going over concrete.

The second time we out laminate down it was much easier and came out a lot better then the first time. The laminate still had that hollow feeling when you walked on it though. The 2 different laminates that we put down both are much louder when you walk/roll a chair on too, so I’m not sure if that makes a difference to you or not. One of the other things I don’t like about the laminate is that it expands on contracts so you could have it nice and tight when you install it, but when it contracts you could have some air gaps in your flooring later on. I think the trick is to only install the wood when it is already contracted, so that when it expands it does so under the baseboards where you won’t notice it.

I will tell you that both times putting the laminate down wasn’t nearly as bad as redoing all the baseboards.

Post some pics when you are done and let us know how it turned out. Good luck.
 
Ricky, I think you may have missed the main reason why YOU want the laminate!

"My wife found some really pretty laminate called Arkansas Oak that she wants down instead."

grin.gif
grin.gif
grin.gif
 
Originally Posted By: claimbusterRicky, I think you may have missed the main reason why YOU want the laminate!

"My wife found some really pretty laminate called Arkansas Oak that she wants down instead."

grin.gif
grin.gif
grin.gif




Even this old bachelor knows that if momma ain't happy ain't nobody going to be happy.
 
if it is a high quality laminate, you will be pleased with it, and as said before..... "My wife....wants instead." Go with the laminate....If you start square, start on the correct side, it will move rather quickly. I have installed both on several occasions. I like hardwood personally, but a good quality laminate is really beautiful too, and in some cases it's hard to tell the difference.

let me know if I can help you in any way.

rb
 
I'm wondering why your are putting down the 5/8s if you already have a 3/4 plywood down already. That is major overkill unless your joists are pretty far apart. I've put down 1000s of ft of both hardwood and laminate and have never had to do that.
 
is this Cabin a home? I was gonna install it in my hunting cabin and was told the Laminate companies will not warranty it in seasonal use applications!I work for a "major" home inprovement store and talked with the flooring installers on this.
 
Back
Top