Winchester Gun Safe

MrHornet

New member
Are the winchester safes any good? The one I am looking at is the one that Sam's Club carries. I don't like the electric key pad but the price is right compared to most. They run about $625. Here are the specs from their site.

59"H X 28"W X 22" D* 12/24 Convertible Interior
Fire Rating - 1 hour at 1200F
Burglary Resistant
3-Way Active Bolt Work
12 each - 1.25" Diameter Locking Bolts
5-Spoke Vault Handle
Electronic Lock
Drill Resistant Hard Plate - 60-61 Rc
Auxiliary Spring - Loaded Relocker
Insulated Door - 1.5" thick
Insulated Body - 1.375" thick
 
The rating of Burglary Resistant is separate from the Fire rating on most safes....

Many safes have a degree of fire protection, but can be peeled, or punched, pretty easily..

The "Burglary Resistance" rating gives an indication of how much relative protection a safe will provide from an experienced attack.
 
I have one of the Winchester safes that you see at Sam's Club. Mine actually came from Wal-Mart for some reason and was kinda nicked up. I got it for $450. A little Testors model paint and good as new!

I think as safes go, it's a good safe for the money. I love the electronic lock. Mine's 5 years old and I changed the battery after 2 years with no problems.
 
It will usually be listed with the safe info.... You just have to watch which laboratory did the testing... If it's Underwriters Laboratory, that's that national standard...Consumer's Reports is another good testing resource..

Some will say they were tested, but the quality of the test may be suspect...You just have to do your "Due Diligence" in the research.

If someone tries to breach the doors, will the locking bolts automatically be locked in place?? Or if the dial is compromised?? Also check to see if there is a thin plate used on the bottom, as that is where the more experienced thieves attack by just flipping the safe over on the back/side and the plate can fairly easily be popped off for access..

I'm not giving away secrets here since most good thieves already know them (the jails are their schools)... it's the buyers that don't know what questions to ask, or look for.. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smiliesmack.gif /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smiliesmack.gif
 
Now I just need to decide if I am going to dump one of my toys to protect the rest with a better toy box.

I was looking at the safe more for the fire protection and to keep prying eyes off them (I don't share well) more than the theft part. I figure if they want them they will get then and it will be more inviting to find a big shiny safe and wonder what treasures are inside. If they look at the glass on the old wooden one and only see an abolt and a lady smith that is of any value and that the rest are all just shooters that will weight them down. they will use the time to rid me of my TV instead. This is the good part of not being able to afford the good stuff.
 
check with a reputable locksmith in your area. they should give you the best answer on a "burgler proof" safe for the money.
 
I have one in my garage, its my dads safe and for the money I think its a pretty good buy. He paid between 5 and 600 for it from Sams Club. Its got the dial lock on it, he got it years ago. You wont get it open with a pry bar and it tips the scales at just over 500 pounds and its fire rated. It will keep the thieves out, remember if it looks like it might be hard and time consuming for them, they generally pass it up.

I park my Harley next to my gun safe, in hopes they steal that before messing with my guns!
 
I'll give you some more info on safes tonight when I have more time. As far as the electronic locks go, run, don't walk away from them. It's not if they fail, it's when they fail. When they do, it is very expensive to get them open, and it does a lot of damage to your door. The damage can be repaired, but the paint is ruined. Stay with a dial type lock. One tip on them, if you put pressure on the handle, you should not feel any resistance on the dial when you turn it. You do not want a safe with a "direct dial" lock on it. They are not much better than your high school locker padlock.
John
 
I have one of the Winchester safes but mine came from wally world. It does have holes in the bottom so it can be secured to the floor. For the money it seems to be a good buy.
 
I purchased a Remington (Liberty) last year with the money I was saving for another gun. I decided then that the worsening economy was going to increase the theft. Not that there has been much theft in my area, just I live out of town and if someone did break in they would have plenty of time to haul off stuff during the day.

I placed mine in the garage and bolted it to the concrete slab. I bolted it for two reasons: 1) as Old Turtle commented, thieves will do anything to get into a safe, and 2) just in case one of my kids or thier friends decided to use the safe as a jungle gym I didn't want them fooling around and tipping it over. Not that I think kids could tip over a 500 lb safe with hundreds of pounds of stuff in it, but I've learned to never underestimate kids. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif

I purchased mine at Gander Mountain because they were running a decent sale. Mine came to about $725 including tax and the dehumidifier.
 
Quote:
Now I just need to decide if I am going to dump one of my toys to protect the rest with a better toy box.



Sacrifice?

GJ
 
Quote:
Quote:
Now I just need to decide if I am going to dump one of my toys to protect the rest with a better toy box.



Sacrifice?

GJ



You add up what you have spent in firearms and whatever else you would put in there and the choice is easy.
 
OK, I have a little more time now.
Just so you know, I make a living opening, repairing, selling, and servicing safes. I have worked in the locksmith industry for over fifty years, and with safes for twenty five of those years. I hope this info helps some of you.
If you are going to buy a gun safe, you will get what you pay for. A good safe costs money. Look for a "Underwriters Labratories Label" for your fire protection. Make sure the words Underwriters labs are on that label. If it is not there, it was rated in the country it was imported from, and the rating will not mean a thing to your insurance company. It is almost useless. Most good safes hafe a 2 hour rating. That is what you want. No less than a 1 hour rating. Look around the door edege, where it meets with the opening. You want to see a fabric like fire gasket. This will help keep out water and smoke, as well as heat in a house fire.
Just because the locking bolts are large, does not mean they are heavy duty. If the mechanisim they are connected to, (the boltworks), is flimsey, you don't have the protection you think you have. Usually, there is not much protection of the bolts them selves with hardened steel, so they are suseptable to hardware store drill bits, battery drills and punches. Ask your dealer if you can have them remove the inner door panel so you can see inside the door. Tee heavier the mechanisim, the more strength you have.
Look for a door that is recessed into the box. They are much harder to pry open. Also, you don't want exposed hinges for obvieous reasons.
As I said befor, stay away from the electronic locks. Sooner or later, they will become a nightmare. I work on mechanical locks that are well over 100 years old almost weekly, and they have very little problems. With the electronic locks, almost anything can and will cause a problem with them. They are very convienient while they work, but just when you really need them, they fail. Even the Sargent & Greenleaf 6120 electronic lock you can get on the high end safes, in my opinion is garbage. If it goes bad, and the safe has to bee drilled, it can take as much as five holes to get it open. They can all be patched, and most of them will be covered by the new keypad, but at least one of them will be exposed. Repainting an expensive safe with a high gloss finish can cost as much as repainting a fender on you car! Probably, the best mechanical lock on the market for a gun safe is a Sargent & Greenleaf model 6730. It is almost identical to the locks used in many banks for their undercounter safes, and very similar the ther locks used on the main vaults. They should come as standard equipment on most good safes. The electronic locks can cost you upwards of $150.00 additional
as an upgrade!
Most safes have holes in their floors so you can anchor them to something. Mine is bolted to the floor of my garage with five 5/8" bolts, into the concrete, and washers and nuts inside the safe. It is not going anywhere. It is also alarmed, and booby trapped as well. The wrong person messing with it is going to have a really bad day.
One last thing. Many stores will throw in a Golden Rod device to help with moisture inside the safe. They are good, but if the safe is not prepped at the factory for one of these, drilling a hole in the top, back, or sides will dramatically compromise your fire proofing.
I use a small can of cat litter in all my safes. Just use a can about the size of a tuna fish can. Clean it well, and fill it with the cat litter. I use the litter with the green stuff in it. It smells better. Cover it with some saran wrap, and poke some holes in the saran wrap. Put one up high, and one on the floor. I change mine about every three years when I remember. I have never, ever, had any rust on any of my guns, and I have been doing this for about 25 years. It works, and it is very cheap.
I hope this information helps you all. I know I get a little windy at times, but I hate to see someone spend their hard earned cash, and not get what he thinks he is getting.
John
 
Quote:
Safecracker thanks for the post. It helped me. Rick



Would you care to recommend a particular brand and model? If not would you send me a PM with the info. Thanks
 
Thanks for the write up very helpfully I will defiantly hold off on th electric lock I was already leary but this sealed the deal. Now to figure out a reasonable safe with manual lock. I can find in the area.
 
Back
Top