dimecovers3:
I don't believe I said there was a "dramatic advantage" of one over the other...those are your words.
And no...there is not "some extra step done to the shoulder in loading after fire forming". The shoulder is slightly pushed back on the 223 Rem case and formed to a 30 degree shoulder to make a Tac 20 case, and many folks use a FL sizer die to do this and also neck the case down in one step. I use a separate form die to do the same thing.
I merely responded to the recent theme about the Tac 20 requiring a lot of "extra effort" that's being tossed out by people who don't really know the facts. It really doesn't require any more than a little effort to make good Tac 20 brass. Like Remington shooter stated, if you can resize a case, you can probably make Tac 20 brass. To me, saying that about the Tac 20 is kin to folks saying that "all 17 Remingtons foul badly" even though the folks saying it have often never owned or maybe never even shot a 17 Remington.
In addition, I have yet to see a Tac 20 that wouldn't shoot to the same or very nearly the same point of impact with both fire formed brass and new pre-fire formed brass, so the idea of wasting barrel life with fire forming is pretty much a myth with the Tac 20 from my perspective. Every round I've ever shot in one of my Tac 20's was shot at something worth shooting at, and not just to fire form brass so I could later shoot at something worthwhile.
Maybe re-read my post above and also Remington Shooters post for more clarification on what I was saying.
Beyond that, I did state I liked the Tac 20 over the 204 Ruger, but I don't think I tried to make one a Cadillac and the other a Chevy....if they are in your mind, that's fine with me....but that's not my impression. I own two of each...
I do like the Tac 20 because it is a little more efficient case than the others with a longer case neck, but I mainly just like something that not everyone else has. If I could only own one of them, it would be the Tac 20.
Also, I don't think the cloudy skies between Kindler, Lapau, and Dakota is going to cause the Tac 20 to become extinct any time soon. I know I would not have spent almost a dollar each for brass from Dakota that is so easily formed. In addition, dies are available in several places, including Midway and Sinclair (Redding) and Kindler, for about the same cost as any other non-factory round. And like you stated...it just shoots 20 caliber bullets.
What the "Wrath of Things to Come" means is beyond me...??? LOL!! But, if you think Tac 20 brass is hard to make, you definitely won't like the 20 BR or the 20 PPC....especially "if you like the idea of high quality brass ready to go."
Another great 20 caliber option is the 20 Vartarg....IMHO, but there's no "high quality brass ready to go". But the end results are well worth the small effort required in making the brass for it, too.
-BCB